By Dr. Sabina Nagpal, Founder of Radiate Mind
Dr. Sabina Nagpal is a Canadian-trained Psychiatrist (Medical Doctor) who transitioned from treating serious mental health conditions to now helping startup teams in high-growth mode. She combines psychiatric expertise with performance oriented holistic practices to support rapidly-expanding business teams prevent burnout.
To make it easier for you to read this article, we suggest downloading it in PDF Format.
For investors, the transition of a search fund entrepreneur into the CEO role marks a critical juncture. This period isn’t just about financial performance; it’s about setting the stage for sustainable success. A CEO’s first year can make or break an acquisition, and how investors engage during this time can significantly influence outcomes.
What does effective investor involvement look like? Based on insights from a number of seasoned investors and Search Fund Entrepreneurs, here are key strategies to help ensure a successful first year with your CEO:
1. Redefining metrics for success
Short-term results can be tempting to track, but they don’t always reflect long-term impact. Instead, focusing on cultural integration, strategic alignment, and trust-building provides a clearer picture of a CEO’s effectiveness.
Key questions to consider:
- How well is the CEO connecting with the company’s internal culture?
- Have they identified and engaged key stakeholders?
- What steps are they taking to build trust and collaboration?
By shifting the focus from immediate returns to relationship-driven indicators, investors can better assess long-term success.
If you’re looking for a structured approach to measure these factors, I offer tailored assessments to help investors navigate this critical first year.
2. Promote open and authentic communication
The first year is rife with uncertainty and unanticipated challenges. CEOs often hesitate to voice concerns, fearing it may undermine investor confidence. Normalizing vulnerability is crucial to building open communication and trust.
Questions investors can ask to open dialogue:
- “What have you encountered that you didn’t expect?”
- “What’s your biggest challenge right now?”
- “Have you regretted buying this company?”
While the last question may seem provocative, if trust and non-judgement is established in the relationship, it is one of the most effective ways to encourage honest reflection and uncover hidden stressors. Acknowledging and accepting these normal experiences as part of the early journey can help prevent more significant issues down the line.
3. Encourage the CEO to lead from a fulfilled state
High-stress leadership often leads to overdrive—a state where CEOs work tirelessly but lose perspective. This not only drains their energy but also blocks their ability to inspire and innovate. Investors can play a pivotal role by encouraging practices that promote a “fulfilled state.” This state fosters creativity, intuitive problem solving, and prioritization.
Practical steps:
- Advocate for periodic pauses to reflect and recalibrate.
- Support coaching or mentoring programs that help CEOs develop self-awareness and unhook from psychological traps.
- Encourage them to connect with a peer network of other search fund CEOs, where they can share experiences and insights.
The neuroscience is clear: “When CEOs operate from a fulfilled state, they’re better equipped to handle complexity, make strategic decisions, and inspire their teams.”
4. Building trust through supportive investor involvement
Investors should approach check-ins with a mindset of “What can I give?” rather than “What can I get?” Beyond financial backing, offering a collaborative space for discussion strengthens the entrepreneur’s journey. Instead of directives, act as a sounding board, share personal challenges to normalize struggles, and foster an open environment where CEOs feel safe to voice concerns.
Ways to build trust:
- Schedule regular, non-intrusive check-ins.
- Provide guidance as a sounding board rather than issuing directives.
- Offer resources that support both business and personal growth.
5. Recognize the emotional complexity of the role
Investors have a lot to gain by being mindful of the emotional weight of being a first-time CEO. From managing legacy employees to navigating their own imposter syndrome, search fund entrepreneurs face immense psychological pressures. Acknowledging this and offering support goes a long way for both your relationship and your bottom line.
Simple yet impactful actions include:
- Creating a space where challenges can be discussed openly.
- Validating their feelings of uncertainty, perhaps even some form of regret.
- Reassuring them that missteps are a natural part of growth.
Conclusion: partnering for long-term success
The first year of CEO leadership is as much about emotional resilience as it is about strategic execution. For investors, this means going beyond traditional oversight to become a trusted ally. By fostering open communication, prioritizing well-being, and expanding success metrics, investors can ensure their CEO’s growth aligns with the company’s long-term trajectory.
A final piece of advice I once heard: “Never bet on a workhorse. Bet on a leader who can inspire and grow.” Your role isn’t just to monitor that growth—it’s to cultivate it.
By approaching the first year with empathy and intentionality, investors can lay the groundwork for not just a successful acquisition, but a thriving partnership.
